Fraud Blocker
top of page
Harbourview Therapy Logo

Achilles Tear: Surgical vs Non-Operative Treatment?


Surgery or non surgery for Achilles tear ?

Achilles rupture, one of the most common debilitating injuries affecting the lower leg, often requires intense medical care. In many cases, surgical intervention is considered the standard of care. However, new studies reveal alternative, non-operative treatment options with similar outcomes. This article will explore the efficacy of operative intervention versus non-operative treatment for Achilles ruptures.


What is an Achilles Tear?

The Achilles tendon is the largest tendon in the body, connecting the calf muscles to the heel bone. Achilles tendon ruptures commonly occur while playing sports that require high-level movements, such as running or jumping. The rupture may also arise from a sudden, forceful dorsiflexion of the foot. Symptoms of Achilles rupture include a sharp pain in the heel accompanied by a popping sound.

Operative Intervention

Surgical intervention typically involves opening up the tendon sheath, suturing the torn tendon edges together, and reinforcing them with additional sutures or anchors. This allows the tendon to heal back together properly, increasing tensile strength and counteracting any muscle imbalances. When treated surgically, patients typically require six to nine months of rehab to recover their full range of motion and strength.

Non-Operative Intervention

Non-operative treatment for Achilles tendinopathy includes exercises, heel raises, and specialized rehabilitation protocols under the oversight of a physical therapist. While significant ruptures may still require surgical intervention, new research indicates that non-operative treatment leads to similar outcomes for partial ruptures.

So What Now?

The critical question is: Is surgical intervention always necessary for typical Achilles ruptures? Recent studies by Soroceanu et al. and Oinonen et al. suggest that non-operative treatment of partial and complete tears of Achilles can lead to satisfactory results in terms of function, restore full strength, and prevent re-rupture. However, surgical intervention in cases of significant ruptures is still recommended.


In conclusion, a patient's decision to undergo operative intervention or non-operative treatment for an Achilles rupture can depend on the severity of the injury. While surgical intervention remains the recommended treatment option for significant tears, patients with partial tears, after weighing the alternatives, might consider best opting for alternative, non-operative options. The right approach will be assessed by experienced and knowledgeable physicians to guarantee each individual's optimal care. Knowing the potential benefits and drawbacks of both treatment options will help patients make informed choices regarding their medical care.

Comments


bottom of page